Dog training collar, also known as shock collar, has always been a controversial tool in the dog training field. If used properly, these training tools can be useful to help correcting deleterious habits in dogs.
Here are our reviews and buyer’s guide to help you find the best one for your furry friend.
Our Top Picks for The Best Shock Collars for German Shepherds
- Educator E-Collar – Best Overall
- DOG CARE Training Collar – Runner Up
- Dogtra EDGE Long Range Remote Dog Training E-Collar
- SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers E-Collar
- Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar
Warning: you should use shock collars only on dogs that understand basic commands like sit and stay. That way your dog understands what you’re asking of them.
Best German Shepherd Shock Collar Overall
1. Educator E-Collar
The Educator German Shepherd Training Collar is perfect for correcting undesirable behavior (such as digging in the garden or excessive barking) and reinforcing positive behavior.
It is different from most training collars in the market. First of all, it uses a blunt stimulation to deliver a tap sensation instead of a sharp static shock like most products do.
This tapping sensation, similar to vibration, is less stressful for your GSD but as effective as the traditional “shock” method. You can adjust the intensity of the vibration based on the weight and size of your dog.
The stimulation can be increased or decreased based on the weight and size or sensitivity of your German Shepherd. You can choose the stimulation levels from 1 to 100 with additional boost stimulus are from 1 to 60.
For a better training result, the Educator includes a Pavlovian Tone feature. With this feature, you can train your GSD to respond to the tone rather than the stimulation itself.
Another exciting thing to note is the option for training more than one dog at a time with a range, ranging from 1/2 mile to 3/4 mile.
Many dog owners who bought this collar said they saw positive results in weeks. A few did complain that the battery life was poor.
- Delivers a light tap sensation with 100 different stimulation levels
- Available from a 1/2 mile to 3/4 mile range
- Waterproof receiver and remote control
- Two sets of contact points (5/8″ and 3/4″)
- Mini ergonomic stopwatch transmitter which allows the user to control a flashing light to help locate your dog in the dark
- Poor battery life and high cost
2. Dog Care Dog Training Collar
The Dog Care Dog Training Collar has three different modes for training: beep, vibration, and shock modes.
For most dogs, the vibration and noise modes are enough to get a positive response.
If you still need to use the shock modes, there are 99 different levels of a static shock to choose from and a security keypad lock to prevent accidental shocks.
The keypad lock is not a button on the keypad but a physical slide/button on the side of the transmitter so you don’t need to worry it will accidentally unlock.
This collar has a remote range up to 330 yards so you can let your dog run in the dog park and still correct them from far away.
Moreover, with a single remote, you can control up to 9 different collars, which allows you to train multiple dogs at the same time. They are easily adjustable to accommodate different dog sizes and holds up well in rainy, muddy, or snowy conditions.
The vast majority of dog owners were very impressed with how easy it was to use and the immediate effect that it had on their dogs. A few users, however, found the receiver was a little too bulky.
- Three training modes
- A single remote can control up to 9 collars
- Strong signal, up to 330 yards (1000 ft) remote range
- In-built security keypad
- Long battery life
- Charges with micro-USB
- Some reviewers noted that the remote was too large and the collar didn’t stay tight
3. Dogtra Edge Remote Training E-Collar
The Dogtra Edge Dog Training E-Collar has an impressive remote range of 1 mile. It has three training modes (Nick, Constant, and a Pager vibration) with customization options up to 127 levels.
The huge range of simulation levels means you can increase or decrease the stimulation depending on your dog’s size and temperament.
It allows for the simultaneous training of up to 4 dogs. The light function is quite nice too. With this feature, each collar can have its own unique color light.
Also, the LED light is quite bright, which is very useful to track and see where your buddies are at night.
- 1-mile maximum range
- Three training modes
- 127 simulation levels
- User-controlled LED light
- Designed for dogs 35 pounds and up
- Lack of bark control simulation
4.SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers
If you’re looking to train your German Shepherd for hunting or other sporting purposes, the SportDog Brand 425 Remote Trainer can be a great option.
Designed to fit dogs 8 pounds and up, this dog training collar has a maximum effective range of up to 500 yards. And the ability to train up to 3 dogs with a single remote control transmitter; though, you’d have to buy the additional collars.
What makes this product great for outdoor lovers are the waterproof feature. It’s not just waterproof against rain; it’s fully submersible in the water at a depth up to 25 feet!
- 7 levels of static stimulation with momentary or continuous mode
- Waterproof and submersible up to 25 feet
- 500-yard range
- Allows for 3 dogs
- Comes with a training DVD
- A little stiff and a bit hard to use than other brands
5. Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar
The Pet Union PT0Z1 is one of the most popular collars among both aspiring and experienced dog trainers. Many trainers use it to train medium to big-sized dogs weighing 10 to 100 pounds like German Shepherds.
This collar is waterproof and comes with four modes of operation, including beep, light, vibration, and shock. It has a long-range of 1,200 ft and comes with four-mode training simulations with customization levels from 1-100 for both the static stimulation and vibration modes.
Although, a few dog owners complained that it did not work at extended ranges.
The LCD comes in blue backlighting for clear visibility at all times. And it uses a rapid charging lithium-ion battery with an automatic sleep mode feature to help prolong battery life even more.
The Pet Union PT0Z1 is backed by a lifetime replacement guarantee. Most people also loved the expert advice they received from the company.
- Four training modes: light, tone, vibration, and static
- Excellent transmitter range of up to 1200 ft
- Long-lasting, rechargeable lithium-ion battery with auto power feature
- 1-100 customization levels
- Lifetime replacement guarantee
6. Petrainer Shock Collar for Dogs
The Petrainer Dog Training Collar offers three training modes with 100 levels of customization for both the static shock and vibration.
It has a range of 330 yards. The receiver is waterproof, and the conductors are protected with a silicone cover to protect your dog’s skin.
- 100 levels in either the shock or the vibration mode
- Water-resistant receiver
- Up to 330 yards remote range
- 1-year warranty and if you register you’ll get an extended 3 years warranty
- A few users were unhappy with the included collar
7. WOLFWILL Humane No Shock Remote Dog Training Collar
The WOLFWILL Humane is another excellent “no-shock” collar for German Shepherd owners who are concerned about causing their dogs pain.
It’s IPX7 waterproof, has a tone and 16 levels of vibration and light intensity, and works at a range of up to 660 yards.
It features special touch-distinguished buttons designed for blind users in mind that allows you to switch between modes easily.
- 3 modes: tone, vibration, and light
- The maximum effective range of 660 yards
- 1-16 levels of vibration and light
- IPX 7 waterproof
- 2-year warranty and lifetime technical supports
- A few users found the strap was too loose or too tight. And it doesn’t work for small dogs
8. TBI Pro Dog Training Collar
What makes the TBI Pro Rechargeable interesting is its bark detection technology that completely differentiates your German shepherd’s bark from other noises to prevent false triggering.
The smart barking detector is such a helpful feature to reduce false positives, which could negatively impact your German shepherd’s training. Another thing that we find useful is its automatic protection mode. With this feature, it will automatically shut off if activated seven times in one minute, and then will work again in one minute.
The TBI has three training modes and five adjustment levels. Plus, it’s waterproof, so you don’t need to worry about your dog being accidentally injured if he jumps into the water during your camping trip. The battery is rechargeable and lasts up to 14 days per charge, depending on the usage.
Customer Reviews: Many German shepherds owners praised it for its ease of use. One dog parent said, “the collar was a game changer from day one.” A few dog parents complained that the it did not work consistently and did not come with a charger.
9. POP VIEW Bark Collar
The POP View Bark has seven levels of sound and vibration and a sensitivity adjustment. We recommend to always start on the lowest setting possible to avoid startling your German shepherd.
On the lowest setting, the collar emits a short beep to warn your dog. If the barking still doesn’t stop, it then administers a beep plus vibration, and so on up to seven levels.
The sensitivity adjustment allows you to adjust the sensitivity of the bark sensor so your German shepherd won’t be overstimulated. It fits dogs weighing 11 to 110 pounds or with a neck up to 21 inches.
One dog parent said, “it works better than the shocking version.”On the con side, a few dog parents noted that it was slippery and too loose. It also didn’t pick up every time the dog barked.
10. DogRook Rechargeable Bark Collar
The DogRook Bark Control Collar comes with seven levels of correction in both sound and vibration modes.
The automatic protection mode will give you some peace of mind. Once the collar is triggered seven times in one minute, it will enter a one-minute hibernation mode.
It comes with a technology that allows you to increase or decrease the bark sensitivity so that it is only activated when barking reaches a certain decibel level. In addition to two batteries and two-color covers, two sets of plastic prongs are also included with it for different fur types, for both short- and long-haired dogs.
The DogRook fits comfortably on dogs weighing from 10lbs up to 110lbs or with neck size of 9 to 22 inches.
Most dog parents liked that this collar didn’t cause pain or discomfort to their dogs. One customer said that it was the first no-shock collar that had worked on her dog. However, a few reviewers noted that the collar sometimes didn’t register the dog’s bark. And it could be made better; we were unable to find a way to keep it cinched tight.
What is Shock Collars?
Shock collars are a type of training collars that are initially used in the 1960s to train hunting dogs. Today’s shock collars are used as a form of deterrent or correction to negative behaviors such as nuisance barking.
How Does a Shock Collar Work?
It delivers a certain kind of stimulus at the exact moment negative behavior occurs to startle and stop them from continuing whatever they are doing.
The stimulus is not always a static shock but can also be other forms of stimulus such as sound, vibration, and light. Each of these deterrents has a range of intensity that you can set according to your dog’s individual condition like size, weight, and temperament.
You should always set the levels of intensity enough to get your dog’s attention, not to hurt them. To activate these deterrents, you’ll need to use a remote control unit.
Types of Dog Shock Collars
There are three basic types of shock collars currently available in the market, each designed to serve a specific purpose:
Training collars are used mainly in training and correcting any unwanted behaviors your dog may be having.
They come with a receiver and handheld transmitter (controller) and different types of the stimulus—shock, vibration, beep, or light.
Most training collars have a long-range of 330 yards to over 500 yards to 1 mile so you can deliver correction from afar.
As the name implies, anti-bark collars are used to minimize excessive barking. They have a sensor that identifies and delivers a correction every time your dog barks too loud.
If your dog continues to bark, the collar delivers more forceful stimulations until they stop barking.
Boundary Shock Collars
You can use these types of collars to keep your dog from leaving the yard or wandering beyond your property line without using a physical fence.
When your dog comes within a certain distance of the preset area, the collar delivers a specific form of correction to warn them.
What To Look For When Picking A Shock Collar for German Shepherd
The types of shock collars that you buy should correspond to its intended use. Do you need a collar for training your dog, curbing your dog’s excessive barking behavior or keeping your dog from leaving the backyard?
Different shock collars have different maximum effective range. It depends on the area where you are going to train your GSD.
For home training or if you’re only going to use it in your neighborhood, a range of 330 yards are good enough.
However if you have a big yard, or if you want to train your dog outdoor, for example at a hilly terrain, you’ll need a device with a longer range.
All the shock products in this article have 3 to 4 signaling modes. These can include shock, vibration, tone, and light. Having multiple options is a good thing since you don’t know which one that your dog will respond well too.
Therefore, you want to begin with less threatening signaling modes. Start with light or tone modes, then if your dog doesn’t respond well, apply the vibration mode. If your dog still doesn’t comply, use the shock mode as a last resort.
Levels of Stimulation
Modern shock collars often have simulation levels that allow you to decrease or increase the intensity of the stimulus being delivered.
You should start with the lowest setting possible to make sure you’re not hurting your dog.
The shock collars that you choose should fit well and comfortable for your dog.
Before purchasing, take a tape and measure your dog’s neck size. Too tight and the collar can chafe your dog, while too loose it won’t work properly.
Weatherproofed is another key consideration if you want to train your GSD for hunting or outdoor sports.
Bear in mind, though, that the transmitters included with most dog shock collars are only water-resistant not fully submersible.
Ease of Use
The collar should be easy to use, it should have a clearly marked setting and dedicated buttons for different stimuli to prevent confusion and accidental shock.
1. Do Shock Collars Work on German shepherds?
Shock collars can be an effective tool for correcting bad behavior such as excessive barking or jumping on people.
2. Is shock collar safe for my German shepherds?
Today’s shock collar has been equipped with advanced features such as automatic shut off and progression settings to make sure your dog is safe. So yes, when used properly, most bark collars are safe for dogs.
3. How effective is shock collar for reducing barking in German shepherds?
Many studies, such as this one, have backed up the effectiveness of bark collar. When used with rewards training, they can be a useful tool to reduce dogs’ barking behaviors.
4. What is the best training collar for German shepherds?
We recommend the Educator Remote Dog Training Collar as the best training collar for German shepherds.