Should Your German Shepherd Wear a Collar or Harness? (Answered)

Categorized as German Shepherd
collar or harness for German shepherds

You’ve just brought home a beautiful German shepherd puppy and you’re eager to start training them. But first, you need to figure out which type of collar or harness is best for your pup.

You head to the pet store and are immediately overwhelmed by the sheer number of options. Do you need a collar or harness? What size should you get? And what about all of the different colors and styles? It’s enough to make your head spin.

Luckily, our article can help you sort through all of the pros and cons of collars and harnesses to help you make the best decision for your German shepherd.

What is a collar? And What is a harness?

A dog collar is a piece of clothing that is worn by dogs. It is usually made out of leather or fabric, and it has a buckle or clasp that fastens it around the dog’s neck. A dog collar can also have D-rings attached to it, which are used for attaching a leash or other accessories.

In addition to being used for function, dog collars are also often used as a way to express the owner’s personality and style. For example, there are collars that are decorated with rhinestones, and there are even LED collars that light up in the dark.

A dog harness is a piece of equipment that helps to keep a dog under control. It consists of a strap that goes around the dog’s body and another strap that goes around the dog’s neck.

The harness is attached to a leash, which is then held by the person walking the dog. The main purpose of a dog harness is to make it easier to walk a dog without having to hold on to its collar.

This is especially important for dogs that tend to pull on their leash or jump up on people. Dog harnesses come in a variety of sizes and styles, so it is important to choose one that is comfortable for the dog and easy for the person to use.

There are both pros and cons to using a collar or harness with your German shepherd.

Pros of Dog Collars for German Shepherds

Collars can be more convenient

The first benefit of using a dog collar is that it can be more convenient for the owner. This is because your shepherd can wear it all the time. Harnesses, on the other hand, should really only be used when you’re taking your dog for a walk – they’re not meant to be worn all day long.

In addition, collars are often much easier to put on and take off than harnesses. This is especially true for puppies or senior German shepherds that may have difficulty stepping into a harness.

Collars can be used for training

Another advantage of dog collars is that they can be used for training purposes. For example, if you’re trying to teach your dog not to pull on their leash, you can use a collar with a leash attachment to help correct their behavior.

Collars can hold identification tags

When your dog is wearing a collar, they can also wear identification tags. This is important in case your shepherd ever gets lost – the tags will help people know who to contact.

Collars can be fashionable

For those who like to express their personality through their dog’s clothing, collars can be a great option. There are all sorts of different styles and colors to choose from.

Cons of Dog Collars for German Shepherds

Collars may be uncomfortable if the fit is not right

If the fit of the collar is not right, it can be very uncomfortable for your German shepherd. Too tight and it may choke them, too loose and it could slip off.

Collars are not safe if your dog has certain health conditions

If your German shepherd has certain health conditions, such as throat damage or back pain, it is not safe for them to wear a collar. This is because the collar could put unnecessary pressure on their throat or back, which could cause serious damage.

Harnesses may be a better option for German shepherds with these health conditions.

Collars are not safe for dogs that pull on their leash

If your German shepherd is the type of dog that likes to pull on their leash, a collar is not the best option. Not only can this behavior injure their neck, but it can also reduce the amount of air they’re able to take in, making it difficult for them to breathe.

While it’s important to provide some resistance when your dog pulls on their leash, you should never allow them to pull so hard that they start choking themselves.

Certain breeds may be better suited for harnesses

Some breeds of dogs are better suited for harnesses. This is particularly true for brachycephalic breeds, which are at increased risk for tracheal collapse. Collars put pressure on the trachea, which can cause it to collapse.

Pros of Dog Harness for German Shepherds

Harnesses can be more comfortable for dogs than collars

The first advantage of using a dog harness is that they can be more comfortable for the dog than a collar. This is because the pressure from a harness is evenly distributed across the dog’s chest, rather than concentrating on the neck.

Harnesses reduce pulling

One type of harness that is particularly effective at reducing dog pulling is the no-pull harness. These harnesses feature a front leash attachment point that helps to redirect the dog’s attention back to the owner.

Additionally, they often have padded straps that help to distribute the force of the dog’s pull more evenly. As a result, no-pull harnesses can be an effective tool for reducing dog pulling.

Also read: How To Harness Train Your German Shepherd

Harnesses can be safer for certain breeds of dogs

As we mentioned before, some breeds of dogs are at increased risk for tracheal collapse. For these breeds, harnesses are a much safer option than collars.

Harnesses are useful for puppies who are learning to walk on a leash

Puppies are often full of energy and can be difficult to control on a leash. For this reason, many puppies are better suited for harnesses because they provide more control.

Additionally, harnesses can be a good training tool for puppies who are learning to walk on a leash. By using a harness, you can teach your puppy how to walk calmly by your side without pulling.

Harnesses are fashionable too

Just like collars, there are all sorts of different harnesses to choose from. This means that you can find a harness that matches your dog’s personality and style.

Cons of Dog Harnesses for German Shepherds

Harnesses can be more expensive than collars

One of the main disadvantages of using a harness is that they can be more expensive than collars. This is because there are many different types of harnesses to choose from, and some of them are quite specialized.

Harnesses are more difficult to put on

Another disadvantage of harnesses is that they can be difficult to put on. This is particularly true for puppies who are not used to wearing them.

Harnesses can be uncomfortable

Harnesses can be bulky and uncomfortable for some dogs, particularly if they are not properly sized. The extra material can rub against your dog’s skin, causing irritation, and the weight of the harness can add strain to their shoulders and neck.

Harnesses restrict movement

Some harnesses, particularly those that are designed to reduce dog pulling, can restrict your dog’s movement. This can make it difficult for your dog to explore their surroundings and can be frustrating for them.

So, what’s the best option for your German shepherd?

Ultimately, the best option for your German shepherd is the one that is best suited for their individual needs and circumstances.

Here are some conditions that may be better suited for a harness:

  • If your German shepherd is a heavy dog puller.
  • If your German shepherd has certain health conditions, such as throat damage or back pain.
  • If you have a puppy that is learning to walk on a leash.
  • If your German shepherd has a history of orthopedic problems.

While a harness may be more suitable for some activities, collars can be more convenient in other situations. For example, if you’re just going on a short walk or need to step outside quickly, a collar may be more convenient to use.

Where To Get a Collar or Harness for Your German Shepherd?

If you’re thinking about buying a collar or harness for your German shepherd, be sure to do your research and choose the option that is best suited for their individual needs. With so many products on the market, it can be difficult to know which one is right for your dog.

That’s where our reviews come in. We’ve tested out a wide range of harnesses and collars, and we can help you find the perfect one for your German shepherd. We’ll tell you which products are well-made and durable, and which ones to avoid.

So if you’re looking for the best harness or collar for your German shepherd, be sure to check out our reviews. You won’t be disappointed.