=

Are German Shepherds Good With Other Dogs?

Categorized as Training and Behavior
Featured image for an article about german shepherd with other dogs

So you’re considering adding a German Shepherd to your family but wondering – will they get along with other dogs? This is an important question to ask!

While German Shepherds are often portrayed as serious working dogs in movies and TV shows, the reality is that their sociability can vary quite a bit. With proper socialization and training, many German Shepherds thrive in multi-dog households and public spaces. However, maturity and genetics also play a role.

This article will walk you through the key factors that influence German Shepherd dog tolerance, signs of same-sex aggression, and tips for managing multiple Shepherds. Time to unravel the mysteries around this popular breed!

Here’s a quick answer: Whether German Shepherds get along with other dogs depends on several factors like socialization, training, genetics, past experiences, etc. Properly socialized and trained German Shepherds can adapt well to multi-dog homes. However, they tend to become more selective and less tolerant of rude behaviors from other dogs as they mature out of the puppy stage. Careful management of excitement, resources, and tension makes cohabitation smoother.

How The Breed Standard Defines German Shepherd Sociability

According to the American Kennel Club breed standard, the ideal German Shepherd temperament combines confidence and a “certain aloofness.” While not overtly aggressive, they are discernful about dog friendships.

This means that German Shepherd puppies are often quite social, playful and interested in other dogs. However, as they mature, many become more selective, serious, and “fun police” at the dog park.

The United Kennel Club agrees that German Shepherds should not demonstrate shyness, anxiety or nervousness around other dogs. Confidence is key!

Changes To Expect As Your German Shepherd Matures

Between 1-2 years of age, German Shepherds transition from silly adolescents to mature adults. This process often impacts their dog tolerance too! Be prepared for:

  • Lower tolerance – Your Shepherd may start correcting other dogs more sternly for behaviors he previously ignored. For example, jumping up into his face.
  • Increased selectivity – Whereas your puppy played with almost all dogs at the park, your adult Shepherd likely prefers a smaller circle of doggy friends.
  • Decreased sociability – Don’t be surprised if your adolescent Shepherd starts losing interest in playing with unfamiliar dogs. He’s growing up!
  • Fun police mode – Mature Shepherds frequently try to establish order at the dog park by closely supervising play. Other dogs may not appreciate this bossiness!

While frustrating if you’re used to a social butterfly, these changes are a normal part of German Shepherds transitioning from puppyhood into mature adults at their own pace.

What Causes German Shepherds To Attack Other Dogs?

The vast majority of German Shepherds coexist peacefully with other dogs when properly socialized and trained. However, several factors can contribute to outright aggression:

  • Inadequate socialization – Undersocialized Shepherds often feel threatened by other dogs due to lack of experience. Fear leads to defensiveness.
  • Negative experiences – Similarly, scary or painful incidents with unfamiliar dogs teach German Shepherds to go on the offense. Better safe than sorry!
  • Poor training – Obedience skills like a reliable recall put you in better control during dicey situations at the dog park.
  • Rushed introductions – Adding a new dog to your home requires slow, structured integration to avoid tension and fights.
  • Resource guarding – Squabbles frequently erupt over toys, beds, food bowls and attention from favorite people.
  • Medical issues – Pain, illness and conditions like hypothyroidism can cause sudden aggression.
  • Genetics – Skittish, nervous lineages of German Shepherds are more prone to fear-based dog aggression.

In the most severe cases, consulting a veterinary behaviorist may be needed for safe, humane behavior modification.

Are Male Or Female German Shepherds More Dog Aggressive?

CombinationRisk Level
2 femalesHigh
2 malesModerate
Male + femaleLow

While gender doesn’t determine everything, multiple studies show female/female pairings often have the most friction. Male/female pairings tend to do best in multi-Shepherd homes.

Littermate syndrome should also be avoided by not adopting sibling puppies. Raise German Shepherds separately, then integrate later in a structured manner.

Tips For Managing Multiple German Shepherds

If properly socialized and trained, some basic management goes a long way in smoothing over spats between Shepherds. Here are some handy tips:

  • Neuter/spay dogs past puberty to help curb same-sex aggression.
  • Feed dogs separately to prevent resource guarding conflicts.
  • Have multiple water bowls/toys/beds to minimize competition.
  • Train a reliable “leave it” command for when dogs eye each other’s stuff.
  • Rotate walks and play time rather than packing.
  • Praise calm, polite behavior between resident dogs.
  • Consult trainers at the first sign of tension or fights. Prevention is key!

While older or less socialized Shepherds may never enjoy dog parks, they can learn to politely co-exist with housemate dogs with some common sense handling.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are male or female German Shepherds more aggressive?

Two female German Shepherds in the same home are statistically more prone to friction than males. However, poor training, genetics, medical issues and experience also play a role.

Is a German Shepherd a good second dog?

With proper introduction and early socialization, German Shepherds can adapt well to becoming a second (or third!) dog. Key is managing excitement, resources, and tension carefully between resident dogs.

Can German Shepherds live with small dogs?

Many German Shepherds successfully live with small dog breeds. Mindful supervision is especially critical given the size disparity. Manage carefully and praise polite, gentle behavior between your dogs.

When does German Shepherd aggression peak?

Dog-related aggression often emerges as German Shepherds mature out of their playful puppy stage into “teenage” and young adult phases. Around 2 years old, their adult personality becomes clear.

The Takeaway on GSDs and Other Dogs

At the end of the day, proper socialization, training, management and responsible breeding are key to ensuring harmonious multi-Shepherd homes.

While dog tolerance varies in this breed, nurture plays as important a role as nature. Put in the work as an owner, and you may just end up with multiple German Shepherds who live, play and snuggle happily together!

By Andrew Garf

Andrew Garf has loved dogs, especially German Shepherds, since he was 10 years old. Though he also loves burgers, training dogs is his real passion. That's why he created the website TrainYourGSD.com - to help dog owners learn how to properly train, care for, and bond with their German Shepherd dogs.